彩色版混装孤鸿能不能参加比赛？？？

zxken

原則上，我看了 子坎的圖片之後， 覺得 應該會被 WCA擋  因為 稜塊的觀察  的確 可以偷步(對高手來說)

不過最終決定在 WCA 上，要等WCA作出判決。

PS：台灣的魔友及Ron 之前並未看到實際的六色孤鴻，所以可能判斷錯誤!!

不過這二天 應該就會有消息知道能不能參加 WCA啦~~

補上 WCA規定

3h)
No modifications are allowed that enhance the basic concept of a puzzle. Some examples of enhancing the basic concept are: new moves are possible, normal moves are impossible, more pieces are visible, colours on the backside of the puzzle are visible, moves are done automatically, more or other solved states.就是這條規定，使得透明魔方不得參賽!!!!

[ 本帖最后由 zxken 于 2010-7-16 23:04 编辑 ]

zxken

原帖由 夜阑冰河梦 于 2010-7-16 22:10 发表 3d) The colours of puzzles must be solid, the same per colour, and clearly distinct from other colours.3e) Twisty puzzles must either have coloured stickers or coloured tiles.

2010年的版本是這樣的!!
3d)
Puzzles must either have coloured stickers, coloured tiles, textures or painted colours.
3d1)
Puzzles using textures must have different colours on each face to aid in scrambling and judging.
3e)
The colours of puzzles must be solid, the same per colour, and clearly distinct from other colours.
3e1) The stickers/tiles/textures/paint may show an image (in one colour), as long as all stickers/tiles/textures/paint of a colour have the image and the same image.



如果單以方塊顏色來說， 原則上 六色孤鴻可以 以 "painted colours" 來說，就這一點並不違反WCA規定
3e的規定 是指 顏色必需固定在塊體上(不能移動)   
                       並同色要相同且易於分辯(不能紅橘類似到無法分辯是否相同)     [如果我的理解不違背WCA規定的話]
所以單就這二條規定來說，六色孤鴻 "應該" 是符合規定的

zxken

但是有爭議的是我前面貼出來的規定
有爭議的是
3h)        No modifications are allowed that enhance the basic concept of a puzzle. Some examples of enhancing the basic concept are: new moves are possible, normal moves are impossible, more pieces are visible, colours on the backside of the puzzle are visible, moves are done automatically, more or other solved states.

也就是透明魔方被禁止的規定，雖然大煙頭提到 不利觀察，但是透明魔方也是如此，一般來說 有透過透明魔方觀察到後面的顏色也是困難的，但"並非不可"
所以，有可能會因為此規定而被禁止!!

但，這也僅止於我的推測，實際還是要等 WCA 說明!!